Mike Avery

Non League Football

www.mikeavery.co.uk

 

Football Structuring outside of the Blue Square!

Home

Page published 5th April 2011

Football outside the Blue Square Bet regional divisions may need further regionalisation. The current step up has just 3 divisions at Step 3, level 7 of the English league system. The 6 divisions at Step 4 include two around London (Isthmian League) leaving the rest of the country served in-effectively by just 4 divisions, Then at Step 5 there are some county leagues while other leagues cover a huge geographical area and only 12 promotion places for 14 divisions!

Travelling time and distance at Step 3 and Step 4 don't adequately reflect the level (Its the 7th & 8th level of English football) or the support.

Any solution needs to reduce travelling for all teams, whilst maintaining a strong competitive playing standard and allow for adequate promotion and relegation opportunities.

The format below 'merges' the current Steps 3, 4 & 5 into just two steps, Step 3 having 6 Divisions and Step 4 having 18 Divisions.

It is probably not reasonable to consider the Conference changing from it's current format. So it's Step 3 downwards where the pyramid needs to become (much) fatter.

Promotion & Relegation:

Step 2 The only change in the Conference would see 4 relegation places per division rather than the current 3.

Step 3 The 6 champions automatically promoted. The 24 teams finishing in positions 2,3,4 & 5 enter the play offs (See below for how play offs could work). The bottom 4 in each division would be relegated.

Step 4 The 18 champions automatically promoted. The teams finishing in positions 2,3,4 & 5 in each division enter the play offs for the remaining places. The 2 bottom teams in each division would be relegated, however, with only 32 relegation places required, the teams with the best PPG could be reprieved

Step 5 would have 32 Divisions with fixed boundaries (comprising 3 postcode areas* each)

Step 6 having 96 Divisions with fixed boundaries, 1 Division for each postcode area.

Ground grading:

Simple changes needed: The new Step 3 would have the current Step 4 requirement, new Step 4 the current step 5 grading and so on.

These line ups are just for example only, and should only be considered as such. The teams* used are purely for indicative purposes, they are not necessarily the teams that would make up any revised constitution and are used simply to show the general geographical spread of this type of structure:

*Line ups based on League positions as at 30th March 2011 Step 3 comprises of the current Step 3 plus the top half of each current Step 4 division. Step 4 comprises the bottom half of the current Step 4 plus all of Step 5 and a couple of Step 6 teams to make the numbers up to 20 per division.

Step 3
  Northern League Prem Div   Midland League Prem Div   Eastern League Prem Div  
Team From Team From Team From
Ashton Utd 3 NPLPD Barwell 4 NPLD1S Arlesey Town 4 SLD1C
Bamber Bridge 4 NPLD1N Buxton 3 NPLPD Aylesbury 4 SLD1C
Bradford Park Avenue 3 NPLPD Chasetown 3 NPLPD Banbury United 3 SLPD
Brigg Town 4 NPLD1S Chester  4 NPLD1N Bedford Town 3 SLPD
Burscough 3 NPLPD Cinderford Town 4 DLD1SW Biggleswade Town 4 SLD1C
Chorley 4 NPLD1N Colwyn Bay 3 NPLPD Brackley Town 3 SLPD
Clitheroe 4 NPLD1N Evesham United 3 SLPD Bury Town 3 ILPD
Curzon Ashton 4 NPLD1N Halesowen Town 3 SLPD Cambridge City 3 SLPD
Frickley Athletic 3 NPLPD Hednesford Town 3 SLPD Carlton Town 4 NPLD1S
Fylde 4 NPLD1N Kidsgrove Athletic 4 NPLD1S Daventry Town 4 SLD1C
Goole  4 NPLD1S Leamington 3 SLPD Glapwell 4 NPLD1S
Halifax Town 3 NPLPD Matlock Town 3 NPLPD Grantham Town 4 NPLD1S
Kendal Town 3 NPLPD Mickleover Sports 3 NPLPD Hitchin Town 4 SLD1C
Lancaster City 4 NPLD1N Nantwich Town 3 NPLPD Hucknall Town 3 NPLPD
Marine 3 NPLPD Newcastle Town 4 NPLD1S Leighton Town 4 SLD1C
North Ferriby United 3 NPLPD Northwich Victoria 3 NPLPD Lowestoft Town 3 ILPD
Ossett Town 3 NPLPD Romulus 4 NPLD1S Needham Market 4 ILD1N
Salford City 4 NPLD1N Rushall Olympic 4 NPLD1S Retford United 3 NPLPD
Skelmersdale United 4 NPLD1N Stourbridge 3 SLPD Rugby Town 4 SLD1C
Stocksbridge Park Steels 3 NPLPD Sutton Coldfield Town 4 NPLD1S Sudbury 4 ILD1N
United of Manchester 3 NPLPD Warrington Town 4 NPLD1N Woodford United 4 SLD1C
Whitby Town 3 NPLPD Witton Albion 4 NPLD1N Worksop Town 3 NPLPD
           
Western League Prem Div Southern League Prem Div Isthmian League Prem Div
Team From Team From Team From
Almondsbury Town 4 SLD1SW Bedfont Town 4 SLD1C Aveley 3 ILPD
Bashley 3 SLPD Bognor Regis Town 4 ILD1S Billericay Town 3 ILPD
Chippenham Town 3 SLPD Burgess Hill Town 4 ILD1S Brentwood Town 4 ILD1N
Cirencester Town 3 SLPD Carshalton Athletic 3 ILPD Canvey Island 3 ILPD
Didcot Town 3 SLPD Chesham United 3 SLPD Concord Rangers 3 ILPD
Frome Town 4 SLD1SW Croydon Athletic 3 ILPD Cray Wanderers 3 ILPD
Gosport Borough 4 SLD1SW Dulwich Hamlet 4 ILD1S East Thurrock United 4 ILD1N
Hungerford Town 4 SLD1SW Harrow Borough 3 ILPD Enfield Town 4 ILD1N
Mangotsfield United 4 SLD1SW Hemel Hempstead Town 3 SLPD Faversham Town 4 ILD1S
Marlow 4 SLD1C Hendon 3 ILPD Folkestone Invicta 3 ILPD
North Leigh 4 SLD1SW Horsham 3 ILPD Grays Athletic 4 ILD1N
Oxford City 3 SLPD Kingstonian 3 ILPD Harlow Town 4 ILD1N
Paulton Rovers 4 SLD1SW Leatherhead 4 ILD1S Hastings United 3 ILPD
Salisbury City 3 SLPD Metropolitan Police 4 ILD1S Heybridge Swifts 4 ILD1N
Sholing 4 SLD1SW Slough Town 4 SLD1C Hornchurch 3 ILPD
Swindon Supermarine 3 SLPD Sutton United 3 ILPD Maidstone United 3 ILPD
Taunton Town 4 SLD1SW Tooting & Mitcham United 3 ILPD Maldon & Tiptree Town 4 ILD1N
Thatcham Town 4 SLD1SW Walton & Hersham 4 ILD1S Margate 3 ILPD
Tiverton Town 3 SLPD Walton Casuals 4 ILD1S Ramsgate 4 ILD1S
Totton 4 SLD1SW Wealdstone 3 ILPD Romford 4 ILD1N
Truro City 3 SLPD Whitehawk 4 ILD1S Sittingbourne 4 ILD1S
Weymouth 3 SLPD Wingate & Finchley 4 ILD1N Tonbridge Angels 3 ILPD
           

 

 

These line ups are just for example only, and should only be considered as such. The teams used are purely for indicative purposes, to show the general geographical spread of this type of structure:

 

 
Step 4
  Northern League Northern Div   Northern League Western Div   Northern League Eastern Div  
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Ashington 5 NLD1 Ashton Athletic 5 NWCLPD Armthorpe Welfare 5 NCELPD
Bedlington Terriers 5 NLD1 Atherton LR 5 NWCLPD Billingham Synthonia 5 NLD1
Bishop Auckland 5 NLD1 Bacup Borough 5 NWCLPD Billingham Town 5 NLD1
Consett 5 NLD1 Barnoldswick Town 5 NWCLPD Bridlington Town 5 NCELPD
Dunston UTS 5 NLD1 Bootle 5 NWCLPD Farsley 5 NCELPD
Durham City 4 NPLD1N Brighouse Town 5 NCELPD Garforth Town 4 NPLD1N
Esh Winning 5 NLD1 Colne 5 NWCLPD Hall Road Rangers 5 NCELPD
Jarrow Roofing 5 NLD1 Flixton 5 NWCLPD Harrogate Railway Athletic 4 NPLD1N
Newcastle Benfield 5 NLD1 Formby 5 NWCLPD Long Eaton United 5 NCELPD
Newton Aycliffe 6 NLD2 Leigh Genisis 4 NPLD1N Norton & Stockton Ancients 5 NLD1
Penrith Town 5 NLD1 Liversedge 5 NCELPD Nostell Miners Welfare 5 NCELPD
Ryton 5 NLD1 Mossley 4 NPLD1N Ossett Albion 4 NPLD1N
Shildon 5 NLD1 Padiham 5 NWCLPD Parkgate 5 NCELPD
South Shields 5 NLD1 Radcliffe Borough 4 NPLD1N Pickering Town 5 NCELPD
Spennymoor Town 5 NLD1 Ramsbottom United 5 NWCLPD Scarborough Athletic 5 NCELPD
Sunderland Ryhope CA 5 NLD1 Rossendale United 5 NWCLPD Selby Town 5 NCELPD
Tow Law Town 5 NLD1 Silsden 5 NWCLPD Stokesley SC 5 NLD1
West Allotment Celtic 5 NLD1 Squires Gate 5 NWCLPD Tadcaster Albion 5 NCELPD
West Auckland Town 5 NLD1 St Helens Town 5 NWCLPD Wakefield 4 NPLD1N
Whitley Bay 5 NLD1 Thackley 5 NCELPD Winterton Rangers 5 NCELPD
                 
Midland League Northern Div Midland League Western Div Midland League Eastern Div
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Alsager Town 5 NWCLPD Alvechurch 5 MFA Ardley Utd 5 HLPD
Belper Town 4 NPLD1S Atherstone Town 4 SLD1C Aylesbury United 5 SSMLPD
Biddulph Victoria 5 MFA Bedworth United 4 SLD1C Cogenhoe United 5 UCLPD
Cammell Laird 4 NPLD1N Bishops Cleeve 4 SLD1SW Daventry United 5 UCLPD
Congleton Town 5 NWCLPD Boldmere St Michaels 5 MFA Desborough Town 5 UCLPD
Ellesmere Rangers 5 MFA Bridgnorth Town 5 MFA Dunstable Town 5 SSMLPD
Glossop North End 5 NWCLPD Bromsgrove Rovers 4 SLD1SW Friar Lane & Epworth 5 MFA
Hallam 5 NCELPD Causeway United 5 MFA Irchester United 5 UCLPD
Leek Town 4 NPLD1S Coleshill Town 5 MFA Kidlington 5 HLPD
Maine Road 5 NWCLPD Coventry Sphinx 5 MFA Kirby Muxloe 5 MFA
Market Drayton Town 4 NPLD1S Heath Hayes 5 MFA Long Buckby 5 UCLPD
New Mills 5 NWCLPD Highgate United 5 MFA Newport Pagnell Town 5 UCLPD
Prescott Cables 4 NPLD1N Malvern Town 5 MFA Northampton Spencer 5 UCLPD
Rocester 5 MFA Pegasus Juniors 5 HLPD Oadby Town 5 MFA
Runcorn Linnets 5 NWCLPD Stourport Swifts 4 SLD1SW Old Woodstock Town 5 HLPD
Sheffield FC 4 NPLD1S Stratford Town 5 MFA Raunds Town 5 UCLPD
Stone Dominoes 5 NWCLPD Studley 5 MFA Rothwell Corinthians 5 UCLPD
Trafford 4 NPLD1N Tipton Town 5 MFA Stewarts & Lloyds Corby 5 UCLPD
Winsford United 5 NWCLPD Westfields 5 MFA Tring Athletic 5 SSMLPD
Woodley Sports 4 NPLD1N Willenhall Town 5 MFA Wellingborough Town 5 UCLPD
                 
  Eastern League Northern Div   Eastern League Western Div   Eastern League Eastern Div  
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Arnold Town 5 NCELPD Barton Rovers 4 SLD1C Brantham Athletic   5 ECLPD
Boston Town 5 UCLPD Biggleswade United 5 SSMLPD Debenham LC 5 ECLPD
Coalville Town 5 MFA Blackstones 5 UCLPD Dereham Town 5 ECLPD
Deeping Rangers 5 UCLPD CRC 5 ECLPD Felixstowe & Walton 5 ECLPD
Dinnington Town 5 NCELPD Ely City 5 ECLPD Gorleston 6 ECLD1
Dunkirk 5 MFA Hatfield Town 5 SSMLPD Great Yarmouth Town 5 ECLPD
Heanor Town 6 EMCL Hertford Town 5 SSMLPD Hadleigh United 5 ECLPD
Holbeach United 5 UCLPD Kempston Rovers 6 UCLD1 Haverhill Rovers 5 ECLPD
King's Lynn Town 5 UCLPD Langford 5 SSMLPD Kirkley & Pakefield 5 ECLPD
Lincoln Moorlands Railway 5 NCELPD Peterborough Northern Star 5 UCLPD Leiston 5 ECLPD
Lincoln United 4 NPLD1S Royston Town 5 SSMLPD Mildenhall Town 5 ECLPD
Loughborough Dynamo 4 NPLD1S Sawbridgeworth Town 5 ESL Newmarket Town 5 ECLPD
Loughborough University 5 MFA St Ives Town 5 UCLPD Norwich United 5 ECLPD
Maltby Main 5 NCELPD St Neots Town 5 UCLPD Soham Town Rangers 4 SLD1C
Quorn 4 NPLD1S Stamford 4 NPLD1S Stanway Rovers 5 ECLPD
Rainworth Miners Welfare 4 NPLD1S Stansted 5 ESL Takeley 5 ESL
Shepshed Dynamo 4 NPLD1S Stotfold 5 SSMLPD Walsham le Willows 5 ECLPD
Sleaford Town 5 UCLPD Ware 4 ILD1N Witham Town 5 ESL
Spalding United 4 NPLD1S Wisbech Town 5 ECLPD Wivenhoe Town 5 ECLPD
Wroxham 5 ECLPD Yaxley 5 UCLPD Woodbridge Town 5 ECLPD
                 
Western League Northern Div Western League Western Div Western League Eastern Div
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Abingdon Town 5 HLPD Barnstaple Town 5 Western Andover 4 SLD1SW
Abingdon Utd 4 SLD1SW Bideford 4 SLD1SW Bemerton Heath Harlequins 5 WssxP
Beaconsfield SYCOB 4 SLD1C Bishop Sutton 5 Western Blackfield & Langley 5 WssxP
Burnham 4 SLD1C Bitton 5 Western Bournemouth 5 WssxP
Carterton 5 HLPD Bridgwater Town 4 SLD1SW Brockenhurst 5 WssxP
Fairford Town 5 HLPD Brislington 5 Western Christchurch 5 WssxP
Flackwell Heath 5 HLPD Bristol Manor Farm 5 Western Corsham Town 5 Western
Hallen 5 Western Buckland Athletic 6 SWPPD Fawley 5 WssxP
Highworth Town 5 HLPD Clevedon Town 4 SLD1SW Hamble ASSC 5 WssxP
Holmer Green 5 SSMLPD Dawlish Town 5 Western Hamworthy United 5 WssxP
Merthyr Town 6 WLD1 Ilfracombe Town 5 Western Larkhall Athletic 5 Western
Oxford City Nomads 5 HLPD Longwell Green Sports 5 Western Laverstock & Ford 5 WssxP
Shortwood United 5 HLPD Odd Down 5 Western Lymington Town 5 WssxP
Shrivenham 5 HLPD Radstock Town 5 Western New Milton Town 5 WssxP
Slimbridge 5 HLPD Sherborne Town 5 Western Newport IoW 5 WssxP
Thame United 5 HLPD Street 5 Western Poole Town 5 WssxP
Wantage Town 5 HLPD Wellington  5 Western Romsey Town 5 WssxP
Witney United 5 HLPD Wells City 5 Western Totton & Eling 5 WssxP
Wootton Bassett Town 5 HLPD Welton Rovers 5 Western Wimborne Town 4 SLD1SW
Yate Town 4 SLD1SW Willand Rovers 5 Western Winchester City 5 WssxP
                 
  Southern League Northern Div   Southern League Western Div   Southern League Eastern Div  
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Broxbourne Borough 5 SSMLPD Alresford Town 5 WssxP Arundel 5 Susx1
Chalfont St Peter 5 SSMLPD Alton Town 5 WssxP Ashford Town  4 SLD1C
Cheshunt 4 ILD1N Ascot United 5 HLPD Badshot Lea 5 CCLP
Colney Heath 5 SSMLPD Ash Utd 5 CCLP Banstead Athletic 5 CCLP
Enfield  5 ESL Binfield 5 HLPD Bookham 5 CCLP
Hadley 5 SSMLPD Bracknell Town 5 HLPD Chertsey Town 5 CCLP
Hanwell Town 5 SSMLPD Brading Town 5 WssxP Chessington & Hook 5 CCLP
Harefield United 5 SSMLPD Camberley Town 5 CCLP Colliers Wood United 5 CCLP
Haringey Borough 5 SSMLPD Chichester City 5 Susx1 Corinthian-Casuals 4 ILD1S
Hayes 4 SLD1C Cove 5 CCLP Dorking 5 CCLP
Hillingdon Borough 5 SSMLPD Fareham Town 5 WssxP Egham Town 5 CCLP
Kentish Town 5 SSMLPD Fleet Town 4 ILD1S Guildford City 5 CCLP
Kingsbury London Tigers 5 SSMLPD Godalming Town 4 ILD1S Hanworth Villa 5 CCLP
Leverstock Green 5 SSMLPD Hayling United 5 WssxP Horsham YMCA 4 ILD1S
North Greenford United 4 SLD1C Moneyfields 5 WssxP Mole Valley SCR 5 CCLP
Northwood 4 SLD1C Pagham 5 Susx1 Molesey 5 CCLP
Oxhey Jets 5 SSMLPD Reading Town 5 HLPD Raynes Park Vale 5 CCLP
Potters Bar Town 4 ILD1N Sandhurst Town 5 CCLP Shoreham 5 Susx1
Uxbridge 4 SLD1C Selsey 5 Susx1 Wick 5 Susx1
Wembley 5 CCLP Wokingham & Emmbrook 5 HLPD Worthing 4 ILD1S
                 
isthmian League Northern Div Isthmian League Western Div Isthmian League Eastern Div
Team   From Team   From Team   From
Barking 5 ESL Beckenham Town 5 Kent Chatham Town 4 ILD1S
Barkingside 5 ESL Chipstead 4 ILD1S Corinthian 5 Kent
Basildon United 5 ESL Crawley Down 5 Susx1 Crowborough Athletic 5 Susx1
Bethnal Green United 5 ESL Croydon 5 CCLP Deal Town 5 Kent
Bowers & Pitsea 5 ESL East Grinstead Town 5 Susx1 Eastbourne Town 4 ILD1S
Burnham Ramblers 5 ESL Epsom & Ewell 5 CCLP Eastbourne United Association 5 Susx1
Clacton 5 ECLPD Erith & Belvedere 5 Kent Erith Town 5 Kent
Clapton 5 ESL Fisher 5 Kent Hailsham Town 5 Susx1
Eton Manor 5 ESL Greenwich Borough 5 Kent Herne Bay 5 Kent
Great Wakering Rovers 4 ILD1N Hassocks 5 Susx1 Hythe Town 5 Kent
Hullbridge Sports 5 ESL Holmesdale 5 Kent Lordswood 5 Kent
Ilford 4 ILD1N Horley Town 5 CCLP Norton Sports 5 Kent
London APSA 5 ESL Lingfield 5 Susx1 Rye United 5 Susx1
Mauritius Sports 5 ESL Merstham 4 ILD1S Sevenoaks Town 5 Kent
Redbridge 4 ILD1N Peacehaven & Telscombe 5 Susx1 Sidley United 5 Susx1
Southend Manor 5 ESL Redhill 5 Susx1 Thamesmead Town 4 ILD1N
Sporting Bengal United 5 Kent Ringmer 5 Susx1 Tilbury 4 ILD1N
St Margaretsbury 5 SSMLPD St Francis Rangers 5 Susx1 Tunbridge Wells 5 Kent
Waltham Abbey 4 ILD1N Three Bridges 5 Susx1 VCD Athletic 5 Kent
Waltham Forest 4 ILD1N Whyteleafe 4 ILD1S Whitstable Town 4 ILD1S
                 
                       

 

Step 5

Fixed Boundaries

Please note, Postcode area sets could be joined in many different ways, this is purely a suggestion of one of many possibilities

 

Step 6

Fixed Boundaries

Allocations at step 3 & 4 are ordered by latitude & longitude coordinates. Each division having flexible boundaries, and teams allocated by co-ordinates rather than committees.

Promotion & Relegation

Step 1: As at present

Step 2: Promotion; Champions + Play off winners, 4 teams relegated per division

Step 3: Promotion; Champions + Play off winners, 4 teams relegated per division

Step 4: Promotion; Champions + Play off winners, max of 3 teams relegated per division

Step 5: Promotion; Champions or highest placed team wishing to be considered for promotion. Relegation dependant on maintaining fixed boundaries.

Step 6: Promotion Champions. Relegation dependant on maintaining fixed boundaries.

Step 7 and below: A continuation of fixed boundary leagues, postcodes could be split further to reduce travelling further down.

*Some parts of England have Postcodes associated with Scotland and Wales, these teams would join the nearest appropriate postcode league.

Play offs Step 3:

Champions qualify for automatic promotion. Teams finishing 2md,3rd,4th & 5th in each division qualify for the playoffs

The 6 2nd placed teams plus the 2 3rd placed teams with best ppg (points per game) exempt until 2nd round.

The remaining 16 teams ordered by PPG in the first round. The highest placed ppg at home to the lowest placed ppg team (ie 1st ppg v 16th ppg, 2nd v 15th, 3rd v 14th etc,) (ties to be played mid-week immediately after end of season).

The 8 winners of round 1 joining the 8 exempt teams in the second round. Again the highest ppg playing the lowest ppg remaining teams (ie 1st ppg v 16th ppg, 2nd v 15th, 3rd v 14th etc,) (ties to be played first Saturday after end of season)

The 8 winners of round 2 are again ordered by ppg with the best again having home advantage in the Semi-Finals (ie 1st ppg v 8th ppg, 2nd v 7th, 3rd v 6th, 4th v 5th) Ties played the next mid-week.

The 4 winners contest the two finals again with home advantage to the teams with the best ppg Ties to be played the weekend following the semi's.

Play offs Step 4:

Play offs on the same format as for Step 3.

 

How would a 1,2,4,8,16 format look?

 

 

 

 Prem & Lge   Steps 1 & 2   Steps 3 & 4   Step 5   Step 6  Step 7

 

These maps are only for fun and based only on personal guesses. The actual constitutions will be agreed by the FA and the various League at the AGMs in June 2010. No value should be given to the content and no liability is taken what so ever. The Maps will be updated on a random basis to reflect the latest league positions.

© MGA 2005-2009 (Information from this site may be used elsewhere if acknowledgement is given to www.mikeavery.co.uk) The maps will be restricted by additional copyright(s)